Like many other scholars, I used to think that “nushu” scripts, literally
meaning "women's scripts," are transfigures of those characters
used by the Han Chinese. After working on them over the past 20 years, I have
come to believe that this widely accepted inference is not entirely correct.
I have sufficient reason to say that “nushu”
scripts represent an ancient system of writing signs different from
the system of Chinese characters.
A nationwide survey on ethnic minority languages in the 1950s and 1960s revealed
that the ethnic Yaos had had no written language of their own. This naturally
led to the belief that “nushu” scripts
are transfigures of Chinese characters, thus belonging to the “cultural sphere
of written Chinese.”
I have noticed that areas where “nushu” scripts have been found are inhabited
almost exclusively by ethnic Yao people. Wherever they are found, “nushu”
scripts are remarkably identical or similar in both structure and meaning,
as well as in the shapes of their strokes. This fact suffices to prove that
these scripts form a system of writing signs different from the system of
Chinese characters.
Even more important is the fact that from among “nushu” scripts I have identified
many that are in fact “borrowed” from scripts on oracle bones left over from
the Yin-Shang period about 3,000 years ago. To put it another way, these “nushu”
scripts are identical with scripts on oracle bones in structure. Far
back during the Zhou period (11th century BC-236 BC), scripts on oracle bones
were beginning to ceased to be used and, as result, had remained unknown until
oracle bones bearing them were unearthed in the late 19th century. This fact
suffices to prove that “nushu” scripts
represent a very ancient system of writing signs. In other words, “nushu” scripts are as ancient as scripts on oracle
bones and may have been closely associated with scripts on oracle bones.
From among “nushu” scripts I
have found many pictographs that look like birds complete or partial in view.
I assume that these pictographs were created at a time when the bird was taken
as a totem. Only when bird was taken as a totem would it have been possible
for the prehistory people to use a pictograph of the bird head to denote the
human head, and a pictograph of the complete bird to denote the human body.
There are also “nushu” pictographs
resembling the rice plant in different stages of growth, rice cultivation
and rice food. Obviously, these were created after wild rice species had been
domesticated and people had begun growing rice for food.
China is one of the first few countries to grow rice. Direct evidence to this
has been found in numerous ruins of the old and new stone ages. One of these
is the site of Hemudu culture that existed in what is now Zhejiang Province
7,000 years ago. Lots of rice seeds and other rice-related relics were unearthed
when the site was excavated for the first time from the autumn of 1973 to
the spring of the following year. Basing themselves on all these, scientists
calculated that the annual rice output could be as high as 120 tons.
But, why is it that “nushu” was eventually reduced to oblivion .
My textual research may provide a clue to this question. In 1704, the 43rd
year of the reign of Emperor Kang Xi of the ’ing Dynasty, Li Laizhang, head
of the local government, ordered burning of all texts bearing ethnic Yao writing
signs. The official had been infuriated because the ethnic Yaos refused to
study those Confucian and other classics imposed on them by the government.
The order was executed without delay, and virtually all texts with ethnic
Yao writing signs were destroyed.
But there are still questions that need to be answered. Are these ancient
ethnic Yao writing signs “nushu” scripts?
May I be bold enough to infer that to preserve their written language, women
embroidered their ethnic writing signs on their aprons which, as time went
by, eventually became “nushu” scripts, scripts used exclusively by women.
I am not sure whether my inference is correct. To put it in a nutshell, more
study is needed to crack the mystery surrounding those “nushu” scripts.